0xf6e7501d…6aa9sent to0x6f3e6272…223d·#25,724,962·view on Etherscan
TL;DR: This is a for-profit partnership whose benefits flow primarily to the proposer's own tourist business, with an unenforceable off-chain profit-share and no verified Noun ownership,…
The scooter fleet is a commercial venture at a site the proposer co-owns, making the proposer both applicant and primary beneficiary — the direct, verifiable benefit to Nouns is a 20% profit-share that exists only as an off-chain promise with no onchain mechanism, failing I.7's requirement of both direct benefit and mission alignment (self-dealing concern under IV.3). Under I.8 a partner must verifiably own a Noun before approval, and no such ownership is shown, which is treated as unmet. The proposer's genuine Nouns art track record is noted, but the partnership subsection overrides the below-cap default and sets AGAINST absent enforceable deliverables.
[ suggestions ]
- Embed enforceable profit-sharing and reporting via milestones or streaming rather than an off-chain future agreement
- Have the partner acquire and verifiably hold a Noun before resubmitting per I.8
- Direct funds to a named business entity with independent oversight to reduce self-dealing risk
more @ nounsvote.com