0xcb06bede…b9ccsent to0x6f3e6272…223d·#19,617,250·view on Etherscan
Torn on this one, ultimately agree with Coral & Brennen. With Coral mainly on small aesthetic things, with Brennen on the desired origin of new Nouns heads.
Majority of "For" votes right now come from people with an arguably vested interest. Personally I'd like Nouns heads to be "Nouns Originals" and not be directly affiliated with any sub-organization.
+1
> As a Noundry founder, I'm committed to having the DAO incorporate new traits from community artists. However, there's a risk of the collection becoming 'diluted.'
> Its CC0 nature already pushes Nouns design space to the extreme, so when it comes to onchain pixels, I believe we should stick to the underlying canon as much as possible.
>
> This is why I’m voting against this proposal: I like the design but don’t think it integrates well with the original collection.
>
> There are too many details and small elements, an excess of shadows and not enough connection with the noun's collar - making it look unstable.
> This contrasts with the original nouns, which are made of simpler, cleaner shapes and sit well on the shoulders.
>
> 
>
> Also note we probably should avoid mentioning specific brands when submitting cc0 pixels.
>
> Sorry for voting against this time, a big thank you Brett for contributing so many traits to the gallery and for testing the trait-to-candidate flow! It will be interesting to see if the DAO can make curatorial votes.
+1
> Love the squirt gun! However, I think Nouns should have OG art that people then use as CC0. I don't like the idea of using art from Yellow Collective or other Sub-communities. But damn the Squirt head rocks!