memoscan
← all memos

Memo 0x62275dc5…f2e693 on Ethereum

I’d like to see a V2 of this proposal. I’m not convinced starting at 1,000 GIFs is the right scope. I’d rather see a smaller, more curated batch first with a strong quality bar and much clearer category focus before scaling up further. My biggest concerns are category focus and avoiding repetitive or low-effort edits. I’d like to see a more defined breakdown of the types of GIFs being prioritized and the overall creative direction behind them. I’d still like to see a lot more examples beyond the single dog-sniffing GIF, which didn’t seem at the same level as some of the stronger Nounish GIF work already out there. I think at least 10 examples would help voters better evaluate the creative direction and overall quality. I do like the cadence of releasing the GIFs over time instead of dropping everything at once. That approach makes sense. I agree with the broader goal here. Lil Nouns should absolutely have a stronger GIF/reaction presence across the interwebs If this version doesn’t pass, I think a tighter V2 with stronger examples and a more defined creative direction could absolutely get broader support. I’d be happy to help champion that version and help rally votes around it.