0x56b6dcdd…44d8sent to0x156e94a6…d7e3·#18,552,028·view on Etherscan
I have a few reservations about this prop that I mentioned in discord:
- I feel like there's a lot of different things in this prop that could be more focussed over less time (some were removed since my first feedback which was good to see).
- The amount is based on an arbitrary scale that was created by community members, which I appreciate the time going into setting that up, but I don't think it's a great precedent to set because then shredders just aim in those levels. I suppose this was the goal, but I would prefer every proposal and value proposition be evaluated isolated and based on its merits rather than a set scale which sets up expectations that may not get support when votes come in. A socially enforced consensus is an odd one and may not reflect onchain, so setting a scale might be misleading.
- The amount seems pretty high - not that Will does not deserve it, but for the value that Gnars will see. I keep coming back to how will this increase auction participants when evaluating proposals and it's not entirely clear here for me.
- I love the 2 video elements of this prop and these are primarily why I am voting in favour here. I hope to see these minted so people can collect forever. I'd be happy to chat/help with that aspect when the time comes.
- There is no doubt Will is a valuable community member and I want to support him. But I hope to see some solid outcomes from this prop to restore my faith in funding shredders ahead of time for work to be done.
I really wish we could afford to just have a Gnars team that is paid to do the things they love, and I think this is possible one day, but not without auctions popping off. It might take a while, but I do believe we're set for this future.
And I think we're fortunate to have such passionate people in the community already, so thank you Will, and everyone else for that matter!
Was a hard decision, please make Gnars proud.